Avvo Rating 10
Dui Defense
Super Lawyers

Birmingham AL Domestic Violence Lawyer

Birmingham AL Domestic Violence Lawyer

Attorney Mark Polson in a courtroom holding a book, with American and Alabama flags behind him.

A domestic violence accusation in Alabama carries consequences that reach far beyond the courtroom. A conviction could mean jail or prison time. You could lose your right to own a firearm. You may face child custody restrictions, steep fines, and lengthy probation. A conviction can also damage your career. Alabama's domestic violence statutes define offenses including domestic violence in the first degree, domestic violence in the second degree, and domestic violence in the third degree, and are built on the state's assault laws including assault in the first degree, assault in the second degree, and assault in the third degree. Every domestic violence case is, at its core, an assault case. Defending it requires an attorney who understands both.

Being accused does not mean you will be convicted. The criminal defense attorneys at Polson & Polson, P.C. have extensive experience defending people charged with domestic violence throughout Alabama. Our attorneys handle these cases in courts across the state. We represent clients in Birmingham municipal court and Jefferson County District Court. We also serve courtrooms in Shelby, Baldwin, Madison, Mobile, Tuscaloosa, and Lee counties. If you face a domestic violence charge anywhere in Alabama, contact Polson & Polson, P.C. for a free consultation to discuss your case.

What Is Domestic Violence in Alabama?

Domestic violence in Alabama is a label added to an underlying criminal offense. The relationship between the accused and the alleged victim determines whether the label "domestic violence" applies.

The victim must be a current or former spouse. The victim may be a parent, step-parent, child, step-child, grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild, or step-grandchild. The victim could be a co-parent or present household member. The victim may also be a person who has had a dating relationship with the defendant. A "household member" excludes non-romantic or non-intimate co-residents. A dating relationship means a current or former relationship of a romantic or intimate nature. It must involve the expectation of affectionate or sexual involvement by either party.

As an example, consider this scenario. Defendant D and Victim V get into a fight. Defendant D punches Victim V. Victim V receives a small cut and a black eye. Defendant D could be prosecuted for Assault 3rd.

But suppose Defendant D and Victim V are current or former spouses, co-parents, household members, or have had a dating relationship. In that case, the label and charge of domestic violence will be added. Defendant D would be charged with Domestic Violence – Assault 3rd.

Domestic violence charges in Alabama may be classified in numerous ways. They include both misdemeanors and felonies. Offenses include Domestic Violence 1st, Domestic Violence 2nd, Domestic Violence 3rd, Domestic Violence Strangulation Suffocation, and Interference With a Domestic Violence Emergency Call.

The range of underlying criminal offenses that can carry the domestic violence label is broad. Assault in the first, second, and third degree qualifies. Menacing and reckless endangerment also qualify. Criminal coercion, harassment, and harassing communications are included. Criminal surveillance and criminal trespass in the third degree qualify. Criminal mischief in the first, second, or third degree qualifies. Arson in the third degree qualifies. Aggravated stalking, stalking, intimidating a witness, and burglary offenses also qualify at the felony DV levels.

This is why so many domestic violence cases are, at their core, assault and threat-based cases. Defending them well requires an attorney who handles both domestic violence and the underlying criminal offenses that drive the charge.

Alabama Domestic Violence 1st Degree

Domestic violence in the first degree in Alabama is a serious felony. Sentences range from ten years to ninety nine years or life in prison. If a firearm or deadly weapon was used, the minimum rises to twenty years. Fines reach up to sixty thousand dollars. Collateral consequences include loss of voting rights. You also lose your right to bear arms. A domestic violence finding also raises a rebuttable presumption against custody with the perpetrator.

A person commits this offense if he or she commits assault in the first degree. This includes aggravated stalking or burglary in the first degree. The victim must be a current or former spouse. The victim may be a parent, step-parent, child, step-child, grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild, or step-grandchild. The victim could be a co-parent or present household member. The victim may also be a person who had a dating relationship with the defendant.

For purposes of this section, a household member excludes non-romantic or non-intimate co-residents. A dating relationship means a current or former relationship of a romantic or intimate nature. It must involve the expectation of affectionate or sexual involvement by either party.

Domestic violence in the first degree is a Class A felony. For a second or subsequent conviction, the defendant must serve a minimum of one year in prison. This term is imposed without consideration of probation, parole, good time credits, or any other reduction in time.

The minimum sentence doubles in two situations. First, if a defendant willfully violates a protection order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction. The defendant must also commit domestic violence in the first degree while violating that order. Second, if the offense occurred in the presence of a child under age fourteen. The child must be the victim's child or step-child. The child could be the defendant's child or step-child. The child may also be one residing in or visiting the household of the victim or defendant.

For purposes of this subsection, "in the presence of a child" means the child was in a position to see or hear the act. The court must make a written finding of fact regarding whether the act was committed in the presence of a child. If a defendant has a jury trial and the jury finds the defendant guilty, the jury must render a special verdict. That verdict addresses whether the defendant committed the act in the presence of a child.

Alabama Domestic Violence 2nd

Domestic violence in the second degree in Alabama is a serious felony. Sentences range from two years to twenty years in prison, with a ten year minimum if a firearm or deadly weapon was used. Fines reach up to thirty thousand dollars. Collateral consequences include loss of voting rights. You also lose your right to bear arms. A domestic violence finding also raises a rebuttable presumption against custody with the perpetrator.

A person commits this offense if he or she commits assault in the second degree. This includes intimidating a witness or stalking. Burglary in the second or third degree also qualifies. Criminal mischief in the first degree is included. The victim must be a current or former spouse. The victim may be a parent, step-parent, child, step-child, grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild, or step-grandchild. The victim could be a co-parent or present household member. The victim may also be a person who had a dating relationship with the defendant.

For purposes of this section, a household member excludes non-romantic or non-intimate co-residents. A dating relationship means a current or former relationship of a romantic or intimate nature. It must involve the expectation of affectionate or sexual involvement by either party.

Domestic violence in the second degree is a Class B felony. For a second or subsequent conviction, the defendant must serve a minimum of six months in prison. This term is imposed without consideration of probation, parole, good time credits, or any reduction in time.

The minimum sentence doubles in two situations. First, if a defendant willfully violates a protection order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction. The defendant must also commit domestic violence in the second degree while violating that order. Second, if the offense occurred in the presence of a child under age fourteen. The child must be the victim's child or step-child. The child could be the defendant's child or step-child. The child may also be one residing in or visiting the household of the victim or defendant.

For purposes of this subsection, "in the presence of a child" means the child was in a position to see or hear the act. The court must make a written finding of fact regarding whether the act was committed in the presence of a child. If a defendant has a jury trial and the jury finds the defendant guilty, the jury must render a special verdict. That verdict addresses whether the defendant committed the act in the presence of a child.

Domestic Violence 3rd in Alabama

Domestic violence in the third degree is one of the most common domestic violence offenses prosecuted in Alabama. It is a Class A misdemeanor under Alabama law. However, a third or subsequent conviction becomes a Class C felony. A prior conviction for domestic violence in the first degree, domestic violence in the second degree, or by strangulation or suffocation also raises this offense to a Class C felony. A conviction from another state for a substantially similar offense has the same effect.

The range of penalty is up to one year in jail and up to six thousand dollars in fines. A municipal court may impose up to one year in jail and a fine of up to five thousand dollars for this offense. Collateral consequences include loss of the right to bear arms.

Domestic violence in the third degree is typically prosecuted in a municipal court. Municipal police officers tend to make most of these arrests. Sometimes this offense is prosecuted in State District Court if the arrest was made by a county deputy or State Trooper.

A person commits this offense if he or she commits assault in the third degree. This includes menacing or reckless endangerment. Criminal coercion qualifies. Harassment or harassing communications are included. Criminal trespass in the third degree qualifies. Criminal mischief in the second or third degree are included. Arson in the third degree qualifies. The victim must be a current or former spouse. The victim may be a parent, step-parent, child, step-child, grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild, or step-grandchild. The victim could be a co-parent or present household member. The victim may also be a person who had a dating relationship with the defendant.

For purposes of this section, a household member excludes non-romantic or non-intimate co-residents. A dating relationship means a current or former relationship of a romantic or intimate nature. It must involve the expectation of affectionate or sexual involvement by either party.

Domestic violence in the third degree is a Class A misdemeanor. If a defendant willfully violates a protection order and commits this offense while violating that order, a minimum of thirty days in jail must be imposed. This term is imposed without consideration of reduction in time.

A second conviction under this section is a Class A misdemeanor. The defendant must serve a minimum of ten days in a city or county jail or detention facility. This term is imposed without consideration of any reduction in time.

A third or subsequent conviction under this section becomes a Class C felony. That carries one year and one day to ten years in prison and a fine of up to fifteen thousand dollars. When determining the number of convictions, municipal court convictions must be included.

Alabama Domestic Violence by Strangulation or Suffocation

Alabama criminal laws have enhanced punishment for conduct involving strangulation or suffocation during a domestic violence event. Domestic violence by strangulation or suffocation is a felony. Sentences range from two years to twenty years in prison. Fines reach up to thirty thousand dollars. Collateral consequences include loss of voting rights. You also lose your right to bear arms. Possible custody limits and other penalties may apply.

A person commits this crime if he or she commits an assault with intent to cause physical harm by strangulation or suffocation. This includes attempted strangulation or suffocation. The person may also commit menacing by strangulation or suffocation. The victim must be a current or former spouse. The victim may be a parent, step-parent, child, step-child, grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild, or step-grandchild. The victim could be a co-parent or present household member. The victim may also be a person who had a dating relationship with the defendant.

For purposes of this section, a household member excludes non-romantic or non-intimate co-residents. A dating relationship means a current or former relationship of a romantic or intimate nature. It must involve the expectation of affectionate or sexual involvement by either party.

Domestic violence by strangulation or suffocation is a Class B felony under Alabama law. For purposes of this section, specific terms have the following meanings:

Property damage often appears alongside a domestic charge. Our guide to what is criminal mischief explains how Alabama grades that offense and how it is defended.

Strangulation. Intentionally causing asphyxia by closure or compression of the blood vessels or air passages of the neck as a result of external pressure on the neck.

Suffocation. Intentionally causing asphyxia by depriving a person of air or by preventing a person from breathing through the inhalation of toxic gases. This includes blocking or obstructing the airway of a person by any means other than strangulation.

Alabama Criminal Offense of Interference With a Domestic Violence Emergency Call

Alabama domestic violence laws have criminalized interfering with someone making a 911 call or call to the police during a domestic violence emergency. This offense is punishable by up to six months in jail and up to three thousand dollars in fine. Municipal court penalties are capped at five hundred dollars.

This offense is defined as follows. A person commits the crime of interference with a domestic violence emergency call if he or she intentionally hinders or obstructs the victim. Disconnecting the call or preventing the victim from calling for assistance in any way also violates the statute.

Interference with a domestic violence emergency call is a Class B misdemeanor. Not every argument that brings police to the scene ends in a domestic violence charge. Some are charged instead as disorderly conduct, a Class C misdemeanor.

Assault Defense in Alabama Domestic Violence Cases

Because Alabama's domestic violence statutes are defined by direct reference to the state's assault laws, a domestic violence defense is fundamentally an assault defense. The prosecution must prove every element of the underlying assault charge. It must also prove the required relationship between the accused and the alleged victim. An experienced assault defense lawyer handling a DV case attacks both layers.

Assault in the first degree requires the State to prove that the defendant caused serious physical injury. In the most commonly charged form, that injury must have been caused by a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument. The defendant must have intended to cause serious physical injury. Or the defendant acted under circumstances showing extreme indifference to human life. This is the assault that powers a domestic violence in the first degree charge.

Assault in the second degree covers intentionally causing serious physical injury, with no weapon element required. It also covers causing physical injury with a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument. When the relationship element is present, this becomes domestic violence in the second degree.

Assault in the third degree covers intentionally or recklessly causing physical injury. This is the most commonly charged level. Paired with the domestic relationship, it becomes domestic violence in the third degree.

Alabama does not use the phrase "aggravated assault" in its criminal code. People searching for an aggravated assault lawyer should know that comparable charges under Alabama law are assault in the first degree and assault in the second degree. Both are felonies. When the protected relationship exists, they become domestic violence in the first degree or domestic violence in the second degree. These carry some of the most severe penalties in the state's criminal code.

A criminal defense attorney for assault in the domestic violence context may raise several defenses depending on the facts. Self-defense allows a person to use physical force when they reasonably believe it is necessary. The force must defend against the use or imminent use of unlawful physical force. Alabama's stand your ground law removes the duty to retreat. That applies to a person not engaged in unlawful activity who is somewhere he or she has a right to be. Defense of another person is also justified under the same statute.

Other defenses include lack of intent. This is particularly important in third degree assault cases. The State must prove the defendant acted intentionally, recklessly, or with criminal negligence using a deadly weapon. Challenging the physical injury element is common because prosecutors must show actual physical injury, not just contact. The relationship element itself may be challenged if the parties do not meet the statutory definition. Depending on the facts, charges like resisting arrest may also arise during these encounters. Cases involving a weapon or a claimed serious injury call for a different approach from cases built on a brief scuffle, so the facts drive the strategy.

False allegations and recantation by the alleged victim arise frequently in DV cases. A recantation does not automatically result in dismissal. But it may weaken the prosecution's case. Fourth Amendment challenges to warrantless arrests and suppression of 911 recordings or body camera footage are additional tools available in criminal defense assault cases.

Talk to a Birmingham Domestic Violence Lawyer Today

Domestic violence cases move fast. Bond conditions, no contact orders, and pretrial hearings may be set within days of an arrest. The earlier you speak with a defense attorney, the more options may be available to protect your rights and begin building your defense. Early legal representation also gives your attorney time to collect evidence and talk to witnesses while memories are still fresh.

Polson & Polson, P.C. offers a free consultation to people facing domestic violence charges in Birmingham and throughout Alabama. During your first call, we will review your charge. We will explain your likely penalty exposure. We will discuss your next court date. We will outline the defense strategies that may apply to your situation. We will also talk through what the charge could mean for jail time, your job, and your long term record. Our criminal defense lawyers handle domestic violence and assault matters across Alabama, and we will tell you plainly where your case stands.

Free Call 24-hour contact banner with phone receiver and clock graphic.

Call Polson & Polson, P.C. today at (205) 871-8838 to speak with a Birmingham domestic violence defense attorney. We accept Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express for your convenience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Domestic Violence 3rd Degree a Felony in Alabama?

Domestic violence in the third degree is generally a Class A misdemeanor under Alabama law. A third or subsequent conviction is a Class C felony. It also becomes a Class C felony if the defendant has a prior conviction for domestic violence in the first degree, domestic violence in the second degree, or by strangulation or suffocation. A substantially similar conviction from another state has the same effect. Municipal court convictions count toward the total.

What Is the Difference Between Assault and Domestic Violence in Alabama?

Assault is the underlying criminal offense. Domestic violence is a label added to that offense when the accused and the alleged victim have a qualifying relationship. Qualifying relationships include current or former spouses, co-parents, household members, or people in a dating relationship. The elements the State must prove for the assault remain the same. The domestic violence label adds collateral consequences, including loss of firearm rights.

Does Alabama Have an "Aggravated Assault" Charge in Domestic Violence Cases?

Alabama's criminal code does not use the term "aggravated assault." The equivalent charges are assault in the first degree and assault in the second degree under Alabama law. When either charge involves a person in a protected domestic relationship, it becomes domestic violence in the first degree or domestic violence in the second degree. Both are serious felonies.

Can an Alabama Domestic Violence Charge Be Dropped if the Alleged Victim Does Not Want to Prosecute?

The decision to prosecute belongs to the district attorney or city prosecutor, not the alleged victim. Even if the alleged victim asks to drop the charges or recants, the prosecutor may move forward using other evidence. Evidence includes 911 recordings, body camera footage, photographs of injuries, or witness statements. A recantation may weaken the State's case, but it does not guarantee dismissal.

What Should I Do if I Was Arrested for Domestic Violence in Birmingham?

Contact a defense attorney as soon as possible. Comply with all bond conditions and any no contact orders the court has set. Do not discuss the case with anyone other than your attorney. Do not contact the alleged victim if a no contact order is in place. Violating that order could lead to additional charges and enhanced penalties. An attorney can review the facts, advise you on what to expect at your next court date, and begin preparing your defense. Our child pornography defense lawyer page covers the other sex-offence charges the firm defends.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Payment Plans
Fill out the contact form or call us at (205) 871-8838 to schedule your free consultation.

Reach Out Today

We Accept the Following Payment Solutions

American Express LogoVisa LogoDiscover LogoMastercard Logo